Do totals finish the way they moved (up toward the Over, down toward the Under)?

NFL games from 2023 to 2026, graded against the closing line. Pick a question, narrow it with the filters, and read the hit rate against break-even.

Went with the move
48.2%
of totals finished the way they moved
Within the margin of error of break-even ⓘ
35%break-even 52.4%70%
242–260 record
502 games
44–53% 95% range
502 decided games · 2023–2026 · every game with a signal

By season

Is it the same every year?
SeasonGamesRecordHit rate
202421096–11445.7%
2025211101–11047.9%
2026 so far8145–3655.6%

By total move size

Bands of edge, and how it did at that size and up
Edge sizeGamesRecordHit rateAnd up
0.5–1247122–12549.4%48.2% 502
1.5–2.513359–7444.4%47.1% 255
3–4.58947–4252.8%50.0% 122
5+3314–1942.4%42.4% 33

502 games

Newest first · showing 50. Tap a game for its card.
GameClosingTotal moveResultFinal
2026 · Week 7
CHI -3 · 50.5 · final 24–30
CHI -3 · 50.5 Up 3 47.5 → 50.5 W O 24–30
2026 · Week 6
SF -7.5 · 51.5 · final 17–23
SF -7.5 · 51.5 Up 1 50.5 → 51.5 L U 17–23
2026 · Week 6
DAL -1.5 · 54.5 · final 13–23
DAL -1.5 · 54.5 Up 3 51.5 → 54.5 L U 13–23
2026 · Week 6
KC -7.5 · 41.5 · final 6–22
KC -7.5 · 41.5 Down 5 46.5 → 41.5 W U 6–22
2026 · Week 6
BUF -5.5 · 54.5 · final 33–30
BUF -5.5 · 54.5 Up 7 47.5 → 54.5 W O 33–30
2026 · Week 6
LAR -13.5 · 51.5 · final 18–16
LAR -13.5 · 51.5 Up 5 46.5 → 51.5 L U 18–16
2026 · Week 6
CHI -1.5 · 50.5 · final 31–23
CHI -1.5 · 50.5 Up 3 47.5 → 50.5 W O 31–23
2026 · Week 6
BAL -3 · 40.5 · final 10–13
BAL -3 · 40.5 Down 4 44.5 → 40.5 W U 10–13
2026 · Week 6
IND -6.5 · 43.5 · final 26–20
IND -6.5 · 43.5 Down 5 48.5 → 43.5 L O 26–20
2026 · Week 6
NO -1.5 · 46.5 · final 34–27
NO -1.5 · 46.5 Up 1 45.5 → 46.5 W O 34–27
2026 · Week 6
CAR -3 · 39.5 · final 25–14
CAR -3 · 39.5 Down 4 43.5 → 39.5 W U 25–14
2026 · Week 6
PIT -2.5 · 37.5 · final 26–19
PIT -2.5 · 37.5 Down 8 45.5 → 37.5 L O 26–19
2026 · Week 6
JAX -2.5 · 42.5 · final 34–31
JAX -2.5 · 42.5 Up 1 41.5 → 42.5 W O 34–31
2026 · Week 6
SEA -3 · 40.5 · final 14–17
SEA -3 · 40.5 Down 3 43.5 → 40.5 W U 14–17
2026 · Week 5
LAR -3.5 · 55.5 · final 37–34
LAR -3.5 · 55.5 Up 2 53.5 → 55.5 W O 37–34
2026 · Week 5
ATL -3 · 44.5 · final 30–23
ATL -3 · 44.5 Down 4 48.5 → 44.5 L O 30–23
2026 · Week 5
DET -4.5 · 55.5 · final 45–21
DET -4.5 · 55.5 Up 6 49.5 → 55.5 W O 45–21
2026 · Week 5
DEN -3 · 42.5 · final 23–17
DEN -3 · 42.5 Down 2 44.5 → 42.5 W U 23–17
2026 · Week 5
CHI -1.5 · 46.5 · final 7–31
CHI -1.5 · 46.5 Down 3 49.5 → 46.5 W U 7–31
2026 · Week 5
HOU -6.5 · 37.5 · final 26–3
HOU -6.5 · 37.5 Down 6 43.5 → 37.5 W U 26–3
2026 · Week 5
CIN -7.5 · 45.5 · final 31–24
CIN -7.5 · 45.5 Down 3 48.5 → 45.5 L O 31–24
2026 · Week 5
NE -8.5 · 51.5 · final 17–45
NE -8.5 · 51.5 Up 7 44.5 → 51.5 W O 17–45
2026 · Week 5
MIN -2.5 · 41.5 · final 23–13
MIN -2.5 · 41.5 Down 3 44.5 → 41.5 W U 23–13
2026 · Week 5
PIT -3 · 42.5 · final 22–34
PIT -3 · 42.5 Down 5 47.5 → 42.5 L O 22–34
2026 · Week 5
WSH -3.5 · 41.5 · final 27–27
WSH -3.5 · 41.5 Down 7 48.5 → 41.5 L O 27–27
2026 · Week 5
JAX -7.5 · 41.5 · final 17–19
JAX -7.5 · 41.5 Down 3 44.5 → 41.5 W U 17–19
2026 · Week 5
DAL -8.5 · 49.5 · final 24–16
DAL -8.5 · 49.5 Down 3 52.5 → 49.5 W U 24–16
2026 · Week 4
NO -1.5 · 48.5 · final 45–24
NO -1.5 · 48.5 Up 3 45.5 → 48.5 W O 45–24
2026 · Week 4
DET -3.5 · 52.5 · final 26–32
DET -3.5 · 52.5 Up 7 45.5 → 52.5 W O 26–32
2026 · Week 4
KC -3.5 · 47.5 · final 30–27
KC -3.5 · 47.5 Up 4 43.5 → 47.5 W O 30–27
2026 · Week 4
SF -3 · 48.5 · final 14–24
SF -3 · 48.5 Up 2 46.5 → 48.5 L U 14–24
2026 · Week 4
SEA -7 · 43.5 · final 23–30
SEA -7 · 43.5 Down 2 45.5 → 43.5 L O 23–30
2026 · Week 4
MIN -10 · 38.5 · final 10–15
MIN -10 · 38.5 Down 5 43.5 → 38.5 W U 10–15
2026 · Week 4
CHI -3.5 · 43.5 · final 12–23
CHI -3.5 · 43.5 Down 2 45.5 → 43.5 W U 12–23
2026 · Week 4
ARI -2.5 · 43.5 · final 24–36
ARI -2.5 · 43.5 Down 2 45.5 → 43.5 L O 24–36
2026 · Week 4
LAR -4.5 · 42.5 · final 24–20
LAR -4.5 · 42.5 Down 5 47.5 → 42.5 L O 24–20
2026 · Week 4
GB -2.5 · 38.5 · final 17–14
GB -2.5 · 38.5 Down 9 47.5 → 38.5 W U 17–14
2026 · Week 4
BAL -11.5 · 41.5 · final 18–24
BAL -11.5 · 41.5 Down 6 47.5 → 41.5 L O 18–24
2026 · Week 4
HOU -3 · 48.5 · final 34–30
HOU -3 · 48.5 Up 1 47.5 → 48.5 W O 34–30
2026 · Week 4
IND -4.5 · 46.5 · final 30–13
IND -4.5 · 46.5 Down 2 48.5 → 46.5 W U 30–13
2026 · Week 4
PIT -2.5 · 38.5 · final 24–27
PIT -2.5 · 38.5 Down 2 40.5 → 38.5 L O 24–27
2026 · Week 3
PHI -3 · 42.5 · final 7–27
PHI -3 · 42.5 Down 4 46.5 → 42.5 W U 7–27
2026 · Week 3
DEN -1.5 · 44.5 · final 26–30
DEN -1.5 · 44.5 Down 1 45.5 → 44.5 L O 26–30
2026 · Week 3
BAL -3 · 54.5 · final 34–31
BAL -3 · 54.5 Up 2 52.5 → 54.5 W O 34–31
2026 · Week 3
NO -3.5 · 44.5 · final 35–27
NO -3.5 · 44.5 Up 2 42.5 → 44.5 W O 35–27
2026 · Week 3
SF -7.5 · 48.5 · final 30–36
SF -7.5 · 48.5 Up 2 46.5 → 48.5 W O 30–36
2026 · Week 3
TB -1.5 · 42.5 · final 23–16
TB -1.5 · 42.5 Down 1 43.5 → 42.5 W U 23–16
2026 · Week 3
BUF -7 · 50.5 · final 16–24
BUF -7 · 50.5 Up 2 48.5 → 50.5 L U 16–24
2026 · Week 3
CAR -2.5 · 41.5 · final 18–21
CAR -2.5 · 41.5 Up 2 39.5 → 41.5 L U 18–21
2026 · Week 3
DET -7 · 49.5 · final 24–31
DET -7 · 49.5 Up 5 44.5 → 49.5 W O 24–31
Total move is the closing total against the opening total; a total that moved up went with the move if the game went Over, and one that moved down if it stayed Under. Every number uses what was known before kickoff: the closing line, the model’s projection made before the game, and the season trend as of that game. The model is the rating model; these records come from the same numbers as the game cards, so they can differ from the Deep dive backtests, a separate run since 2016. Pushes are counted in the games but not in the hit rate. Break-even is 52.4% at -110; the 95% range shows how much a hit rate could move with this many games. History, not a prediction: a hit rate above break-even in the past is not a promise.